The Vikings traded the quarterback they drafted 10th overall to the Giants on Monday for a 2027 fifth-round pick, ending an unusually short tenure after just 10 NFL starts. McCarthy survived roster cuts in August, but he entered the season behind Kyler Murray and Carson Wentz, and Minnesota has now officially moved on from a quarterback it traded up to select just 29 months ago. For the Giants, this is a low-cost swing on a 23-year-old former top-10 pick after losing Jaxson Dart for the season.
And it's another chance for McCarthy to prove he can play in the league. For Minnesota, though, the trade answers the question that has followed McCarthy since the Vikings signed Murray this offseason: how long were they willing to keep waiting? Michigan won a national championship in McCarthy's final college season, went 15-0 and beat Ohio State, Alabama and Washington along the way.
McCarthy completed 72.3% of his passes, threw 22 touchdowns against four interceptions and entered the NFL as a 21-year-old with athleticism, arm talent, toughness and a reputation as a winner. The question was never whether McCarthy could make NFL throws. The question was how often he could make them when his team needed him most.
Michigan rarely required that. McCarthy attempted 332 passes during that 15-game championship season, fewer than 24 per game. During the Wolverines' final four games against Ohio State, Iowa, Alabama and Washington, he threw for a combined 656 yards.
He was efficient, protected the football and made several big-time throws in big moments, but the offense was built around its running game, defense and an infrastructure that rarely asked its quarterback to carry the operation. That was part of my concern in 2024. McCarthy was my QB5 with a second-round grade because the traits were there, but there was still a considerable gap between what Michigan asked of him and what an NFL team would require of him as the face of the franchise.
The tape showed a good athlete with a live-enough arm who could create outside structure and, at times, make high-level throws. But we also saw a quarterback who could become frenetic in clean pockets, struggle to layer the second-level throws and hesitate to pull the trigger on tight-window opportunities. At times, it felt like he didn't trust himself.
Extract — continue reading at the source.
