Sustainability might make for good marketing, but it doesn't guarantee financial success. Surveys and spending data alike indicate that many consumers do value sustainability —and, in some categories, are willing to pay a premium. However, that willingness is highly variable, depending on the product, price point, and the type of benefit offered.
"Many executives, especially in the consumer-packaged-goods (CPG) sector, find that sustainable products still struggle to capture meaningful market share," according to an April report from McKinsey. Consumers may say they want sustainable products, but their actions show that comes with serious caveats. The gap between what consumers say about sustainability and what they actually buy is typically described as an "intent versus action" gap.
Anna Granskog, who leads the European Green Business Building work as part of McKinsey Sustainability, thinks that framing oversimplifies the problem. "As I see it, sustainability on its own is rarely a strong enough driver of purchase behavior to overcome entrenched habits, price sensitivity, and performance expectations. In other words, sustainability is competing against a broader set of decision criteria, and most of the time it's losing," she wrote.
Now, MUD Jeans, a brand built around sustainability, has filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection. A noble mission alone does not pay the bills, which is something the jeans company has learned. The brand explained its mission on its website.
"MUD Jeans exists to eliminate textile waste by keeping denim in circulation indefinitely through repair, resell and fibre-to-fibre recycling. By making circularity the foundation of our business model rather than an afterthought, we aim to demonstrate that fashion can be both commercially viable and genuinely restorative," the company shared. As a consumer who has covered retail for more than 30 years, those words just scream "expensive" to me.
Prices on the company's website back that up. The cheapest men's jeans cost $82.13 as part of a half-off sale, while the priciest pairs come in at $234.78, with many pairs priced between $164.33 and $176.07. For women, the low-end sale prices start at $76.22, while the highest-priced pairs cost $176.07.
Extract — continue reading at the source.
